• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

cinemayward

A Montage of Film Criticism and Theology

  • Cinemayward Home
  • About Joel
    • C.V.
    • Movie Rating System
    • Film Journal (2021)
    • Film Journal (2020)
    • Film Journal (2019)
    • Film Journal (2018)
    • Film Journal (2017)
    • Film Journal (2016)
    • Film Journal (2015)
  • Movie Reviews
  • Essays
  • Top Lists
  • Shop
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • Contact
  • Show Search
Hide Search

The General

May 12, 2009 By Joel Mayward

MPAA Rating: NR | Rating: ★★★★★
Release year: 1927
Genre: Action, Comedy, Silent Director: Keaton, Bruckman

Related

The year of 1927 must have been a banner year for film. That year, the seminal science-fiction film Metropolis, the first Best Picture winner Sunrise, and the first “talkie” blockbuster The Jazz Singer were all released. Included this year is a film that completely flopped at the box office, yet has become an American classic and named as one of AFI’s Top 100 Films.

Buster Keaton’s The General follows the story of Johnny Gray, a simple train engineer operating his train The General during the onset of the Civil War. Johnny has only two loves–his locomotive and his girl, Annabelle Lee. Trying to enlist for the war effort, Johnny is turned away, as train operators are more helpful for transporting supplies than firing cannons. Believing Johnny to be a coward for not fighting in the war, Annabelle Lee shuns him until he is wearing a uniform. When a group of spies from the northern army steals The General, it results in a train chase scene that is incomparable to anything I’ve ever seen. Thrilling, dangerous, and extremely well-timed, Keaton manages to create a fantastic scene filled with humor and adventure. A train chase sounds a bit dull–they’re both on the same tracks, so it can’t be much of a chase, right?–but Keaton manages to create a thrill ride that had me holding my breath. Filled with both sight gags and incredible stunts, the train chase left me wondering “why don’t they make chase scenes like this any more?” There is no choppy camera work or half-second scene cuts; there’s only Keaton and his deep love for The General. Keaton filmed much of the movie in the beautiful Oregon countryside, one of the only places where railroad tracks that accommodate classic locomotives still exist.

Keaton’s strength is in his stoic facial expressions. Every madcap and absurd scene is performed with a completely straight face, as if it were completely natural for him to be sitting on the drive rod of his train engine as it chugs along or to be hiding under a table surrounded by northern soldiers. Unlike the other silent film giant, Charlie Chaplin, Keaton’s humor relies less on silliness and more on his character and the ridiculous situation at hand. There is a depth to Johnny Gray; really, there’s depth to the entire story. While other comedies might include funny scenes simply for the sake of a laugh, The General has a coherent and engaging arc, culminating in one of the best action scenes ever made. There are no useless characters, no gags just for a quick laugh. It’s funny and full of heart.

Leading up to a final train chase that results in one of the most exciting action scenes I’ve witnessed on film, The General is a wonderful silent film that will charm and delight even the most A.D.D. of contemporary audiences. For its timeless entertainment and adept production, this film is truly exceptional in the history of cinema.

Related

IMDB Listing: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0017925/

See all reviews

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print

Related

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Popular Reviews

  • The Shape of Water
    The Shape of Water
  • Fantastic Mr. Fox
    Fantastic Mr. Fox

Recent Essays

  • Top 20 Films of 2020
  • 5 Films: Resurrection
  • The 2020 Cinemayward Oscars
  • Top 20 Films of 2019
  • Top 20 Horror Films

Resources

  • Cine: Superhero $5.99
  • Leading Up $2.99
  • Jesus Goes to the Movies $19.99

Copyright © 2021 · Cinemayward

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.